web stats analysis
« XL 2007 is a big hit with pro gamers | Main | HMV mistakenly lists MGS4 as Xbox 360 release »

Expert investigates cause of Xbox 360's problems

Even though Microsoft has been decidedly cagey about what is actually at the root of the Xbox 360 bricking problem, it has been widely speculated that heat issues were to blame for the more serious and prominent hardware failures. Makes sense really, as heat is basically the main factor that might affect the long term performance of the console. For that reason, Asian website, Tech-On, set a Thermal Design Expert the task of putting two Xboxes (one bought at the end of 2005, one recently repaired by Microsoft) on the examination table to narrow down the cause of the problem.

The result of the analysis seems to confirm what was already suspected – that some of the console’s design features aren’t managing the heat radiation well enough to protect some of the more vital components from long-term heat damage. Some of the more interesting discoveries from the decidedly warranty-breaking investigation are outlined on the turn.

• The temperature of air emitted from the exhaust was about 45°C – about 22°C gap between it and room temperature. The expert explains “it is common to seek a temperature gap of around 10°C between exhaust and room temperatures,”.

One thing I think it’s only fair to add to this statement is that the temperature of the air blown out of my PS3 is probably nearly as hot – I haven’t taken a thermometer to it, but I can easily tell there’s more than a 10°C difference there.

• The cooler fan's maximum wind speed was 1.1 m/s, only 1/2 to 1/3 compared with general desktop PCs. It may be partly because the fan rotation was reduced to lower noise, but it is believed to be a little short on power compared to the console’s size.

• After 15 minutes of normal use, the microprocessor heat sink temperature stabilized at 58°C.

• Meanwhile, the heatsink on the graphics processor LSI shot up to 80°C – some 57°C higher than room temperature. Not much of a concern with the current state of the climate in this country, but across the pond where mid-summer room temperatures might get as high as 35°C, you could be talking about the graphics card heat sink hitting 100°C. Sizzlin’!

• And the difference between the normal console and the repaired one? Err, none. In fact the interior of the fixed model was exactly the same as the other. That could explain the persisting problems then.


Source
Tech-On

Related posts
Xbox 360 processors getting even smaller?
Rumour: Xbox 360 price cut planned for Bioshock release

Came straight to this page? Visit www.xboxer.tv for all the latest news.

Posted by Al W on August 6, 2007 in Hardware | Permalink

Comments

" I haven’t taken a thermometer to it, but I can easily tell there’s more than a 10°C difference there."

That's completely irrelevant because it doesn't matter what the temp gap is if the equipment can handle it. How many PS3's are overheating? Exactly.

You should remember that the PS3 also has the extra temp of the internal PSU to contend with. It funny how it cools all of that with no problems and yet is still quieter than the 360.

I love the way Microsoft aren't even repairing the problem, they are just repairing the damage the problem caused.

Posted by: 78787hrthrthrth665£%$^&*( | August 6, 2007 11:25 AM

"That's completely irrelevant because it doesn't matter what the temp gap is if the equipment can handle it. How many PS3's are overheating? Exactly."

I wasn't trying to imply that this a fault in the PS3 OR Xbox 360 - just wanted to put the expert's 10 degree statement into perspective. Apologies if that could be construed otherwise.

Posted by: Al W | August 6, 2007 11:37 AM

To measure the temp coming out of the box surely does not give a true picture, because if the heat from the gpu/cpu was taken away by the airflow the air temp would be higher.

Posted by: Iain7 | August 6, 2007 12:24 PM

"Testing showed that it would easily heat up to 80°C, and highly likely exceed 100°C in typical summer conditions of 35°C. Interestingly, the 360 repaired in 2007 had exactly the same heatsink"

100C=boiling water temperature
This is bad, real bad design

Posted by: bbOG | August 10, 2007 3:11 AM

The comments to this entry are closed.